Despite my promise last week to discuss what it takes to insulate your privacy from the world's prying eyes, something important has just been decided that I feel compelled to comment on.

At a meeting in Paris the board of the Internet Corporation for Assigned Names and Numbers (ICANN) voted unanimously to 'relax' the rules about which top-level domains (TLD) can be created. In other words, the ICANN board decided the existing TLDs aren't enough and that more should be created.

The current TLDs include .com, .org, .net, .gov, .mil and .edu, country TLDs such as .us, .uk, .tv, etc., and newer bizarre additions such as .info, .coop, .museum, and .pro (that's for "professions" as opposed to, well, whatever else you might have thought).

ICANN's solution to bolster the TLD ranks is to allow any organization with $150,000 to $500,000 (yes, you read that right) to register the TLD of their choosing. This means you'll see TLDs such as .microsoft and .oracle but .gibbs? Not a chance.

Let's see, we've had 15 years of the current TLDs and the system works pretty well. Sure, there are problems but, here's the thing, just having more of the same will simply compound those problems, not fix them. More TLDs that simply exist to cater to the wants of the rich while allowing registrars to make more money selling and managing them are not a good idea.

Let's consider the most recently added domains that were introduced with such pomp and circumstance. Take the .museum TLD: When was the last time you entered a URL that ended in .museum? I'm guessing never. And what's so great about the whole .museum TLD is it means nothing. It's not solely a realm for real museums; the TLD is as commercialized as any other domain!

For example, there's "The Museum of the American Cocktail" – americancocktail.museum – that is sponsored by a flotilla of alcohol companies and which offers seminars in "mixology." I'm all for any kind of museum, but let's not pretend that this is a serious museum like, say, the Getty or the Louvre. And you know what? The .museum TLD is irrelevant to them anyway! For all practical purposes, "The Museum of the American Cocktail" uses a URL in the .org TLD!

So, ICANN let the world have the .museum TLD along with .mobi (for mobile devices), .tel (for communications services), and .job (for companies with jobs available rather than recruitment companies). In other words it allowed a completely random, eccentric and politically motivated set of choices.

Whitepapers

• Advancing the Economics of Networking
• Enterprise Data Center Network Reference Architecture
• Implementing HA at the Enterprise Data Center Edge to Connect to a Large Number of Branch Offices
• File Integrity Monitoring: Secure Your Virtual and Physical IT Environments
• Accelerating a Diverse Mix of Traffic Across the WAN
• Boost Productivity While Cutting Costs with Next-generation Collaboration

View more LANS & WANS whitepapers

Webcasts

• PoE Plus: Impact on the PoE Market
• Creating a high performance workplace with wireless networking
• Harnessing the power of communications to increase workplace performance
• How to cut IT costs with wide-area data services (WDS)
• Making data centers the IT strategic focus
• Protecting assets and employees with IP Video Surveillance

View more LANS & WANS webcasts

Special Reports

• Ethernet Services: WAN options mature
• Keeping Spam at Bay
• Get More From Your WAN
• WAN Optimization: How to rev up sluggish applications
• IP address management in 2008 - six things to know
• Network World Executive Guide: Perfecting Application Performance Management

View more LANS & WANS special reports